A sermon for the 24th Sunday after Pentecost: Proper 27
November 8, 2026, at St. Luke’s Episcopal Church, Hot Springs, AR
Readings: Amos 5:18-24, Psalm 70, 1 Thessalonians 4:13-18, Matthew 25:1-13
There’s a way I’ve always understood this parable. Jesus tells us a parable today about 10 bridesmaids. Five are wise and five are foolish. I’ve always understood that to be us. Some are wise, taking responsibility for their spiritual lives, investing in oil. Some are foolish, not taking time for the things of God, forsaking the oil. The Bridegroom, Christ, shows up. The wise are ready. The foolish are not. Be like the wise ones. That’s the way I’ve always understood it.
That’s a good way to read it. It’s how the early Church Fathers read the parable. Oil was seen as a symbol for righteousness, good deeds, and discipleship. St. Augustine understood the oil to be genuine love for God and neighbor. The wise have it; the foolish just go through the motions and have not love. In the parable they all fall asleep–that is to say, they all die. And when Christ comes again, we see the fruit of our lives. The righteous ones follow the bridegroom into the wedding banquet. The foolish ones with cold hearts are left out in the cold. So the Church Fathers tell us to live our faith with boldness, with integrity, to take responsibility for growing in our lives in Christ. You can’t borrow those things from one another; they are your responsibility. It’s a good message for us today: Take your discipleship seriously. Take your faith seriously. By grace, grow day by day in faith, hope, and love, looking for Jesus to come again. I hope you will hear that message today.
But I have to wonder, what if I’m missing something? I worry about that, you see, because these interpretations make me feel pretty good. They make me pat myself on the back. ‘See, Mark, you’ve got this faith thing figured out.’ They make me think I have religion and spirituality by the tail, and I remember the words of the old proverb: ‘Pride goeth before destruction.’ And as one New Testament scholar tells us, parables are supposed to afflict us, bother us, make us uncomfortable. They are supposed to invite us into a new way of seeing that might set us back on our heels. If they don’t do that, we are probably missing something.
And this ultimately is the fun thing about parables. We can take them, shake them up, turn them over, look at them from the other side, because there is usually more than one interpretation. In the end we hear Jesus calling us to conversion. So while holding on to that traditional interpretation, I wonder if there isn’t another way of understanding it? That’s what I want to do today.
But first, a story. There was this guy in Stuttgart, where I first served as a priest. He came through town every six months. He told me his story, every time. His car had broken down, every time. He was on his way to Jonesboro from Mississippi, and this was his first time in Arkansas–it was his first time in Arkansas, every time. And he needed a little help to get his car going, every time. No, he didn’t need me to call the mechanic. If I could just give him some cash, that would help a great deal and he would be on his way. Well, needless to say, I never gave him cash. I gave him food; I prayed with him; I wished him luck. But every six months, he would come around with the same story.
The last time I saw him was on a Sunday morning. I had seen him earlier that week and told him I couldn’t help, but I gave him what I could: food and prayer. I thought that would be the end, but it wasn’t. We were in church on Sunday morning. The doors were shut. Communion had been distributed. And then, as we began the postcommunion prayer, he snuck in through the door. The congregation was praying, “Eternal God, heavenly Father, you have graciously accepted us…” And this man starts going pew to pew, interrupting the prayer, asking for money. Pew by pew. I gave the blessing. “The peace of God that passes all understanding…” But now there’s a conversation happening in the church alongside the blessing. “I just need a little money to fix my car.” “What? I can’t hear you. Can you wait a few minutes? I’m trying to pray.” And then the final hymn. By now he was midway through the congregation, and I was livid. I grabbed his arm on the way out, and took him outside. I had every intent on reaming him out. I opened my mouth to yell. And I swear, I heard a voice: ‘Mark.’ It stopped me cold. The Holy Spirit convicted me in a flash. I realized I was upset that he had interrupted the prayers, yes; but I was more upset because somewhere deep, dark in my soul, I didn’t think he belonged there on a Sunday morning. Sure, come bother me with your story during the week. I’ll nod and be polite. I’ll do the work of the Church. But don’t show up on Sunday morning. This place isn’t for you. You don’t know the rules; you don’t know how to act right; you don’t look like us. Come back during the week.
Now then, back to the parable. What if we put Jesus, not in the place of the bridegroom, but in the place of the five foolish virgins? That really wouldn’t be a big surprise; Jesus often identifies with the least powerful person in the story. And it’s St. Paul who says the ways of God seem foolish to the world–he uses that word, foolish. And what if we put ourselves in the place of the wise ones and the bridegroom who shuts the door? After all, didn’t Jesus tell us that if we knocked the door would be open? But that’s not what happens here, is it? The door remains shut. What if–and bear with me now–what if we see this sort of backwards?
And you know, there would be a good theological reason to do that. You remember the previous interpretation about the oil being our good works? If we stick with that interpretation, we might run into a problem. We might begin to think that our good works get us into the banquet hall. We might begin to think that our good works get us into heaven. But that’s not what we believe. The only thing that gets us in is the radical grace and love and mercy of God. So maybe there’s a theological reason to look at this a little backwards.
And there are other reasons to think that, too. The words don’t mean what we think. The wise and foolish ones–that’s not quite what it is in the Greek. When we say wise and foolish, there’s a moral component. Wise is good; foolish is bad. But not in the Greek. In Greek, it’s closer to sensible and silly bridesmaids, or even cunning and naive bridesmaids–now that sounds different! Or maybe the Mean Girl bridesmaids and the bridesmaids who have never been to a wedding before and don’t know the right protocol. Or maybe the ones who have it all figured out, who are willing to exclude half the party if it means they get a better seat, versus those who don’t quite know how they made it at all, and they tend to be overlooked and forgotten, the wallflowers in the corner, and they are so gullible that when those mean girls tell them to go looking for oil at midnight, they actually go off and try.
And then we read those naive ones, those foolish ones, show up at the door. Jesus shows up at the door of the church. It’s after hours. It’s not the right time. Oh sure, we’re happy to help at other times. There was a big party before the wedding, and we had a sleepover, and it was great. We’re happy to help at other times. Snack packs are given Monday-Thursday, 9:30-11. We’re happy to help at other times. We may be able to help you find the assistance that you need, Monday-Thursday, Kathy will be in. We’re happy to help at other times. Have you tried the Community Resource Center? They are open Monday-Friday. But when it comes to Sunday morning, you better have your oil. You better have everything together. You better look the part. We’re shutting the door; we do not know you.
In just a few verses (we will hear this in a couple weeks), we will hear Jesus say that as we do to the least among us, we do to him. As we do to the naive ones. As we do to the foolish ones. As we do to the ones who show up every six months… Do you see?
I had dispatched the problem in Stuttgart. I didn’t see the man again. Maybe he had been an angel, I don’t know. Immediately afterward, I stood at the door, saying goodbye and wishing everyone a good week. I was still flushed from the encounter. And someone came through the line. He was a faithful member. He was, I think, my most conservative parishioner, and sometimes he disagreed with me in Bible study or on my sermon. He didn’t look like–he wasn’t–a polished Episcopalian. I love him, and he loves me. He asked me, “Is that man still around?” “No,” I said. “But I’m sure he’ll be back.” He handed me $20. “When he comes back, give that to him. Now I don’t buy the car story, but just give it to him.” And then he asked. “Do you think he’ll be at church next week?” “I would doubt it.” “Well, if he is, I’ll look for him. I’ll make sure he sits by me. He needs to be here, and Jesus wants him here, just like us. I’ll make sure there’s room beside me.”